
How hard is it to count cards?
That’s a more complicated question than it initially seems. Counting cards in any blackjack game, single deck or not, has multiple facets that determine “difficulty.” (See my post about how many decks casinos use for blackjack.)
In many respects, counting cards is easy for someone of average intelligence who’s willing to put in the effort.
Actually making a profit from counting cards, though, is harder than you probably think.
Table of Contents
How Card Counting in Blackjack Works
Card counting is an advantage gambling technique in blackjack.
What does that mean?
In all casino games, including blackjack, the casino has a mathematical advantage — the house edge. To use some kind of strategy to overcome that house edge is called an advantage gambling technique.
Card counting gets you an edge in blackjack because the dealt cards affect the probabilities on subsequent hands. It also works because of the higher payout for a “blackjack” or “natural.”
Because the cards come out randomly, the composition of the deck changes randomly throughout the game, too.
A natural, or blackjack, consists of a card worth 10 and another card worth 11. The only cards in the deck worth 11 are the aces, so those cards are important to counters. Also, only the 10s, jacks, queens, and kings are worth 10 points, so they’re also important.
Best Gambling Sites
| # | Gambling Site | Signup Bonus | Start |
|---|---|---|---|
1 | Slots.lv | 300% up to $7500 | |
2 | Bovada | 100% up to $3000 | |
3 | Ignition Casino | 150% up to $3000 | |
4 | Cafe Casino | 250% up to $1500 | |
5 | BetUS Casino | 200% up to $3000 |
When you have a higher than usual ratio of aces and 10s in the deck than usual, you have a better probability of getting a natural. Since that hand pays off at 3 to 2, you can see how you might get an advantage, mathematically.
Card counters get most of their edge by raising the size of their bets when the deck is relatively rich in 10s and aces.
See also: Can You Count Cards in Online Blackjack?
How Hard Is the Math Behind Counting Cards in Blackjack?
The math used in the most basic card counting systems is easier than you probably think. The most famous card counting system, the Hi-Lo, is probably the best way to illustrate this.
When you’re using the Hi-Lo counting system, you’re only adjusting the count by +1 or -1, depending on which cards come out.
Since the goal is to raise your bets when the deck is rich in 10s and aces, you count -1 every time an ace or a 10 comes out.
And, you count +1 every time a low card comes out. The low cards, for this system, are 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6.
When the count is positive, you bet more.
When it’s negative (or zero), you bet less.
Most people have little trouble adding and subtracting 1 from a running count, so from that perspective, the math behind counting cards isn’t hard at all.
How Hard Is It to Make a Profit from Card Counting in Blackjack?
Any advantage gambler you ask will tell you that having a positive expectation doesn’t mean you’re guaranteed to be profitable. Blackjack is random, so even if you have a mathematical edge, you can hit a losing streak bad enough to make you go broke.
What’s the cure to such streaks of bad luck?
A big bankroll.
If you have a big bankroll relative to the size of your blackjack bets, you can weather longer losing streaks without worrying about going broke. According to Blackjack Apprenticeship, if you have 200 betting units, you have a 40% probability of going broke.
Increase that bankroll to 1000 units instead, and your probability of going broke (your “risk of ruin”) drops to 1%.
What does that translate into in dollars?
Let’s say you’re just getting started, and you’re sticking with the $5 tables. A betting unit is $5, so 200 units would be $1000.
And 1000 units is the same as $5000.
The goal, since you have an edge over the casino, is to stay in the game as long as possible.
If you’re counting cards well enough to have a positive expectation, and if you’re sufficiently bankrolled, making a profit counting cards is almost inevitable and actually easy.
Fiddle with any of those factors, though, and it gets a lot harder to make a profit.
How Hard Is It to Count Cards in Actual Casino Conditions?
Most people learn to count cards at their kitchen table or in their office. They might even use an app on a computer instead of or in addition to an actual deck of cards.
Such people are often surprised at how much harder it is to count cards in actual casino conditions. After all, the casino is an entirely different environment than you’re home.
For one thing, you’re not worried about anyone at home watching you to make sure you’re not counting cards. That’s a concern for most new counters in a casino. Stress makes doing math in your head harder.
Casinos also often deal the cards faster than you’re used to if you practiced at home.
You also have other players at the table trying to make conversation with you. Cocktail waitresses are asking for your drink order. Hundreds or thousands of other gamblers are on the casino floor. The din of slot machines and video poker games makes for a big distraction, too.
It’s harder to count cards in actual casino conditions than most people think.
How Hard Is It to Count Cards in an Online Casino?
It’s possible to count cards in an online casino, but it’s pointless. All online casinos shuffle the deck after every hand. This is true for both the video blackjack games you see at most casinos, and it’s also true for the live dealer casinos where you play with a real dealer via Webcam.
Since the entire premise of card counting as an advantage technique is predicated upon the deck having a “memory,” it’s impossible to get an edge counting if you reshuffle the deck for every hand.
If you want to practice playing blackjack online — or even if you’re just feeling lucky — online casinos are great. You can even practice counting cards at an online casino knowing that the count returns to 0 at the end of every hand.
Just don’t make the mistake of raising and lowering your bets based on the count. That will just increase your variance at the online casino rather than flip the edge in your favor.
Will You Get Caught? What Happens if You Do?
Will the casino catch you counting cards?
What will the casino do when they catch you?
Some of the answer depends on the casino. The MGM in Las Vegas is known for coming down hard on blackjack players.
And don’t worry. They’re not watching you to see if your lips are moving when you count.
They can tell by your betting patterns whether you’re raising and lowering your bets with the count.
If they WANT to catch you, it’s easy. They just track how much you’re betting on each hand. They don’t even care if you’re losing or winning. If they want to ban you for counting cards, they will.
One of two things will happen:
The casino management will advise you that you’re too good a blackjack player, and you’re welcome to play any of the other games in the casino.
Or casino management will ask you to leave and not return. They’ll threaten you with trespassing charges if you try to gamble in their casino again.
The appropriate way to handle being backed off or banned is to politely accept the decision and move on.
You have nothing to gain from arguing with them.
Tips for Prospective Card Counters
I can offer a few tips for prospective card counters:
The first is simple enough — practice. Card counting only offers you the thinnest of mathematical edges even when done perfectly. You’re talking about an edge of 0.5% to 1% if you get it right.
If you get it wrong, you have no edge at all.
And the lower your edge gets, the less money you make from your counting activities.
So, the only way to get good enough at counting cards to have an edge is to practice until counting cards is as automatic as breathing.
The second is to set your sights low. Counting cards isn’t hard, but making a living from counting cards IS hard. I suggest starting with the goal of just having some fun and winning a little money without getting any heat from the casino.
And, to reduce the amount of heat from the casino, use a smaller betting range. When you’re raising the size of your bets based on the count, you want to bet more the higher the count is.
Most counters use a betting range of 1 to 4 units, which means that if they’re betting $5 minimum, the most they’re going to bet is $20.
Someone with a higher betting range, say 1 to 20 units, would bet $5 minimum, but would bet $100 if the deck were really favorable.
The higher your betting range, the likelier you are to get heat from the casino.
Conclusion: How Hard Is It to Count Cards?
It’s not that hard to count cards. Anyone who can handle simple arithmetic can learn to do so.
The hard part is making enough money at it to make it worth your while.
My suggestion is to stick with counting cards for fun rather than as a way to make money.